Fetch vs Nationwide: 2025 Pet Insurance Comparison

Sep 25, 2025

Overview of Fetch and Nationwide Pet Insurance

As pet owners become increasingly aware of the importance of health insurance for their furry companions, choosing the right plan becomes a crucial decision. In this comparison, we delve into what Fetch and Nationwide have to offer in 2025. Both companies are well-known in the pet insurance industry, but they come with distinct features and benefits.

pet insurance

Coverage Options

Fetch provides comprehensive coverage that includes accidents, illnesses, and a variety of other conditions such as hereditary diseases and behavioral issues. They also offer optional wellness coverage for routine care. In contrast, Nationwide provides several plan options, including their Whole Pet plan, which covers a wide range of conditions, and their Major Medical plan, which offers more limited coverage.

One of the standout features of Nationwide is their coverage for exotic pets, something that Fetch currently does not offer. This can be a significant advantage for owners of less common pets.

Cost and Deductibles

When it comes to cost, Fetch offers competitive pricing with a variety of deductible options ranging from $250 to $1,000. This flexibility allows pet owners to tailor plans to their budgetary needs. Nationwide's pricing may be higher, particularly for their comprehensive Whole Pet plan, but they also provide multiple deductible choices.

pet costs

Both companies offer annual deductible models rather than per-incident deductibles, which can be beneficial in managing out-of-pocket expenses throughout the year.

Claims Processing and Customer Experience

Fetch is known for its straightforward claims process. They provide an easy-to-use mobile app that simplifies filing claims and tracking reimbursements. Customers often praise their quick response times and helpful customer service.

Nationwide also offers a user-friendly claims process, although some users report longer wait times for reimbursements. They provide online and app-based claim submissions, making it convenient for tech-savvy pet owners.

pet claim process

Additional Benefits and Features

Fetch stands out with its emphasis on holistic care options, covering therapies such as acupuncture and hydrotherapy. These options appeal to pet owners who prefer alternative treatments. Nationwide's Whole Pet plan includes coverage for vet exams and prescriptions, which might be a deciding factor for some pet parents.

Both insurers offer a multi-pet discount, which can be a great incentive for families with multiple pets. Additionally, Nationwide includes coverage for preventative care in their wellness plans, an aspect Fetch offers as an optional add-on.

Conclusion: Which Should You Choose?

The choice between Fetch and Nationwide will largely depend on your specific needs as a pet owner. If you are looking for comprehensive coverage with the option for holistic treatments, Fetch might be the right choice for you. However, if you have exotic pets or prefer having vet exams included in your plan, Nationwide could be more suitable.

Ultimately, it's essential to compare the specific details of each plan to ensure it aligns with your pet's needs and your financial situation. Both companies provide robust options that can help protect your furry friends in 2025.